City status in Britain has historically had more to do with cathedrals and royal charters than with size, which is why the country contains cities smaller than many villages elsewhere. Several of them are among the most rewarding places to spend a weekend, and almost all of them are quieter than they deserve to be.
Which is the best of them?
Durham, for most visitors. The cathedral and castle sit together on a rock in a loop of the River Wear, forming a World Heritage Site, and the cathedral is generally considered the finest Norman building in Europe.
The city below is small, steep and largely medieval in plan, with riverside walks beneath the cliff. It is twelve minutes by train from Newcastle and on the main line from London, which makes it easy to reach and easy to combine.
What about Wells?
The smallest city in England, in Somerset beneath the Mendip Hills, with a cathedral whose west front carries hundreds of medieval statues and whose interior has extraordinary scissor arches inserted to stop the tower sinking.
Next to it stands the Bishop's Palace, moated and still in use, where swans have been trained for generations to ring a bell for food. Vicars' Close alongside claims to be the oldest continuously occupied residential street in Europe.
Why is St Davids so small?
Because it is a village that happens to hold a cathedral, in the far west of Pembrokeshire. It is the smallest city in Britain by population, with a few hundred residents, and the cathedral sits in a hollow below the settlement so that it cannot be seen from the sea.
The ruined Bishop's Palace beside it is substantial, and the coast path passes within a mile. It makes an excellent base for the Pembrokeshire coast rather than a destination on its own.
Which are worth it for the setting?
Ely, where the cathedral rises out of the flat fens and is visible for many miles, earning it the name the ship of the fens. Its octagonal lantern tower is a unique piece of medieval engineering.
Lincoln, where the cathedral and castle sit on a hill above the lower town, connected by a street called Steep Hill that lives up to the name. The cathedral was for centuries reputedly the tallest building in the world.
Which are good for a quiet weekend?
Chichester in Sussex, with Roman walls, a cathedral, a strong theatre and the harbour and South Downs nearby. Winchester in Hampshire, the Anglo Saxon capital, with a long cathedral, water meadows and good food.
Salisbury, with the tallest spire in Britain, a copy of Magna Carta and Stonehenge a short drive away. Ripon in Yorkshire, with a hornblower who has sounded the watch in the market square nightly for over a thousand years.
Are there small cities beyond England?
Several. Stirling in Scotland, with a castle on a crag, the Wallace Monument and two decisive battlefields nearby. St Andrews, for the golf and the ruined cathedral. Armagh in Northern Ireland, with two cathedrals facing each other on separate hills and an observatory.
Bangor and St Asaph in Wales are both small cathedral cities, and Dunkeld and Kirkwall each hold cathedrals in Scottish towns of modest size.
Why do they stay quiet?
Because they have one major attraction rather than a list, so coach tours pass through in a morning and visitors rarely stay. That is precisely what makes them good for a weekend: a fine building, a small centre you can learn in a day, and evenings when the day visitors have gone and the place belongs to the people who live in it.
How should you plan a visit?
Treat them as a weekend rather than a day trip, and pair them with the countryside around them. Wells sits beneath the Mendips and near Glastonbury and Cheddar. Ely is a short train ride from Cambridge. Durham combines with the Northumberland coast or Hadrian's Wall. Salisbury pairs with Stonehenge and the New Forest. Almost all of them are on or near a railway line, which makes them straightforward without a car, and almost all are small enough that a single afternoon covers the centre, leaving the rest of the time for the area around them.