Skye is the most visited part of the Highlands and the scenery justifies it. The Cuillin ridge is the most serious mountain terrain in Britain, the Trotternish peninsula produces landforms that look invented, and the coastline is exceptional. It is also, between June and August, under more visitor pressure than almost anywhere else in Scotland.
How crowded does it get?
At the well known sites, very. The car parks at the Fairy Pools, the Quiraing, the Old Man of Storr and Neist Point fill early on summer days, and roadside parking around them has caused sufficient problems that verges have been blocked off and charges introduced at several.
The island itself is large, and away from these five or six locations it does not feel crowded at all. The pressure is concentrated at the places that appear in photographs rather than spread across Skye as a whole.
Is it still worth going in July and August?
Yes, with planning. The scenery does not become less impressive because a car park is full, and the long daylight in June and July means you can walk the popular routes at seven in the morning or eight in the evening and have them close to yourself.
What does not work is arriving at midday, expecting to park at the famous sites and doing them in sequence. That produces a day of driving between full car parks.
What should you book in advance?
Accommodation, without exception. Skye has limited beds relative to demand and summer availability disappears months ahead. Restaurants in Portree and the better known places also require booking, and several close one or two days a week outside the peak.
Staying on the mainland at Kyle of Lochalsh, Plockton or Glenelg and crossing daily is a reasonable fallback if the island is full, though it adds driving.
Ferry crossings are the other thing to reserve. The small ferry from Mallaig to Armadale and the Glenelg turntable ferry both carry limited vehicles and both can be full or weather cancelled in season.
Which walks are worth doing?
The Old Man of Storr is short, steep and heavily used, and the path has been substantially rebuilt to cope. The Quiraing circuit is longer, more interesting and includes one exposed section that catches people out in wind. The Fairy Pools walk is easy and the appeal is the water rather than the distance.
For something quieter, the Coral Beaches near Dunvegan, the Point of Sleat, and Rubha Hunish at the northern tip all deliver strong coastal walking with a fraction of the traffic.
Who should not attempt the Cuillin?
Almost anyone without scrambling experience or a guide. The Black Cuillin is the most demanding mountain range in Britain, the rock is gabbro that plays havoc with compasses, and several summits require rock climbing to reach. The Inaccessible Pinnacle is a genuine climb rather than a walk.
Bruach na Frithe is the most straightforward summit for competent hillwalkers. Everything else on the ridge should be approached with proper skills or a hired guide, and mountain rescue call outs on Skye are disproportionately high for a reason.
When is the best time to visit instead?
May and late September. May gives you long daylight, the driest weather of the year statistically, no midges to speak of and far fewer visitors. Late September gives autumn colour, deer, quieter roads and prices that have dropped from the peak.
Winter is spectacular and empty but the daylight is short, some businesses close, and the mountain roads can be difficult. It suits photographers more than general visitors.
How long should you stay?
Four nights minimum. Skye is around fifty miles long with slow roads and multiple peninsulas, and day trips from the mainland see a fraction of it. A common mistake is allocating one night, driving to Portree and the Storr, and leaving with the impression that the island is small and busy.
A week lets you cover Trotternish, Duirinish, Sleat and Elgol properly, take a boat into Loch Coruisk and absorb a couple of wet days without losing the trip.