Almost every first Scottish itinerary tries to include Edinburgh, Loch Ness, Skye and a distillery, because those are the four things everyone has heard of. They are spread across the country and connected by slow roads, and a first trip built around them frequently becomes a tour of the A9. Choosing a region instead produces a much better week.
Who should choose the west Highlands?
Anyone whose mental image of Scotland is mountains, sea lochs and glens. Glencoe, Fort William, Ardnamurchan, Morar and Skye deliver that landscape more completely than anywhere else, and the West Highland Line runs through the middle of it for anyone not driving.
The trade offs are rain, midges in summer and crowding at the well known viewpoints in July and August. This is the busiest part of the Highlands and it is worth visiting in May, June or September if the dates allow.
Who should choose the north and Sutherland?
Visitors who want emptiness. Assynt, Sutherland and the far north coast have mountains rising individually out of moorland, some of the best beaches in Britain and almost nobody on them. The North Coast 500 has increased traffic on the main route, but a mile off it the country is deserted.
This suits confident drivers and independent travellers. It does not suit anyone who wants restaurants, backup plans in bad weather or short journeys.
Who should choose the Cairngorms and the east?
Families, first time visitors nervous about remoteness, and anyone travelling in high summer who wants to avoid the worst of the rain and the midges. The Cairngorms are the largest national park in Britain, the weather is drier, and Speyside adds distilleries and the Moray coast adds beaches and dolphins.
It is also the easiest region to reach and the best served by rail. The landscape is more rounded and forested and less immediately dramatic than the west, which some visitors prefer and others find tame.
Who should choose the islands?
People with time and flexibility. The Hebrides, Orkney and Shetland are exceptional but they run on ferry timetables that weather can cancel, and reaching them costs a day at each end. A first visit that includes one island group works well; one that includes three does not.
Mull, Islay and Arran are the most straightforward to reach and combine well with the mainland. Orkney rewards anyone interested in archaeology more than almost anywhere in Europe.
Who should choose southern Scotland?
Visitors short of time or arriving from northern England. The Borders, Dumfries and Galloway and Ayrshire have abbey ruins, forest, coastline, dark skies at Galloway and a great deal of history, and they are two hours closer than the Highlands from Carlisle or Newcastle.
They are consistently overlooked, which means they are quiet in August when the Highlands are not.
How many regions should a first trip cover?
One, or two if you have ten days or more. A week in the west Highlands, or a week split between the Cairngorms and the Moray coast, will leave you knowing a part of Scotland. A week covering four regions will leave you knowing the road network.
Where do the cities fit?
Edinburgh and Glasgow are both worth two or three days and neither is a Highland base. The practical approach is to bookend a trip with a city rather than trying to run day trips from one, and to use it as the arrival or departure point rather than the centre.
If a first trip has to include both a city and the Highlands, allocate the city at least two nights and accept that the Highland section will be shorter. Squeezing Edinburgh into a single afternoon between drives serves neither well.
Whichever region you choose, the thing that most reliably improves a first Scottish trip is reducing the number of places on the list. Visitors who came back a second time almost always report that they saw more on the shorter itinerary, because they were out of the car and looking at it rather than driving past it.