Worcestershire sits immediately west of the Cotswolds and immediately east of Herefordshire, and costs considerably less than the first while offering a good deal of what people go there for. The Malvern Hills, which are the county's best asset, are free.
How does it compare with the Cotswolds?
Substantially cheaper for accommodation and eating, while being within half an hour of the Cotswold escarpment and holding similar country of its own.
Anyone priced out of a Cotswold village should look at Worcestershire, which is the practical answer that nobody gives.
What is free?
The Malvern Hills entirely, with paths from every road crossing and parking charged only at the main sites, and around a hundred springs and spouts flowing freely.
Worcester Cathedral asks a donation rather than charging admission, which is unusual among the larger English cathedrals.
What charges?
The Commandery, the porcelain museum, the Elgar birthplace and the Severn Valley Railway, all at moderate rates.
The railway is the most expensive single item and is worth it, with rover tickets better value than singles.
What does accommodation cost?
Moderate, with a range from budget chains in Worcester to country hotels around Malvern, and prices well below the Cotswolds for equivalent quality.
The Three Counties Showground holds large events that fill accommodation across a wide area, so check dates.
Where is the cheapest eating?
Worcester city centre and the market towns, with a good pub scene throughout and county produce widely available.
Great Malvern has more expensive options aimed at the spa town trade, and walking ten minutes from the centre improves the price.
What does transport cost?
Rail from London Paddington takes around two and a quarter hours, with advance fares far below walk up ones, and Birmingham is under an hour.
Two stations serve Worcester and Great Malvern is on the same line, which makes a car free trip straightforward.
What are the best value days?
A full day on the Malvern ridge with a packed lunch, which costs only the parking, and an afternoon at the cathedral and the riverside.
The county cricket ground charges very little for a day's play and has the cathedral behind the pavilion.
What else is in the county?
The Severn Valley Railway between Kidderminster and Bridgnorth, Bewdley on the river, and the Wyre Forest, which is ancient woodland and free.
Droitwich, where the brine is salty enough to float in, and Evesham in the fruit growing vale.
What about the Vale of Evesham?
Fruit and vegetable growing country with pick your own operations from June and asparagus in a short season from late April.
Farm shops here are among the cheapest sources of produce in the region.
When is it cheapest?
Winter, when accommodation is at its lowest and the hills are still there. Avoid the show dates and the Cheltenham racing week next door, which affects prices across the region.
Spring and autumn are the best combination of price and conditions.
Is it good value overall?
Yes, particularly as an alternative to the Cotswolds. The hills are better for walking, the towns are cheaper and the crowds are a fraction of those over the border.
Prices move over time, so treat this as a general picture rather than a quotation.
What about the Malvern water?
Around a hundred springs and spouts flow from the hills, several with decorative Victorian surrounds, and many are free to drink from. Filling a bottle at a spout is a genuine local habit rather than a tourist activity. The water made the town's reputation as a spa and the sources are marked on maps of the hills.
One last thought: if the Cotswolds are the plan and the budget will not stretch, the Malverns give better walking, longer views and lower prices half an hour away.
A final practicality: two stations serve Worcester and Great Malvern sits on the same line, so the county's two best days out are both reachable without a car.