A family holiday is judged by a different standard from any other kind of trip. Nobody remembers the view if the week involved three tantrums a day and a two hour drive to every meal. The things that decide whether it works are unglamorous and largely fixed at the booking stage, which is good news, because it means they are within your control.
What matters most?
Proximity. Whether you can walk to a beach, a park, a playground or a footpath from the accommodation is the single biggest determinant of how the week goes, because it removes the daily negotiation about getting in the car.
A modest property within walking distance of something to do beats a better one twenty minutes' drive away, almost every time.
How much space do you need?
More than you think, and more than the sleeping capacity suggests. A property that sleeps six may have one small sitting room, which is fine until it rains and six people need to be in it doing different things.
Look for somewhere with a second room, whether a snug, a dining room or a conservatory. Separation matters enormously with mixed ages, and it is the thing most often missing from otherwise good properties.
What about the journey?
Keep it short. A four hour drive with young children costs a day at each end and sets a poor tone. Somewhere three hours away that you reach in good humour is better than somewhere spectacular six hours away.
This is the most common mistake in family holiday planning: choosing a destination on the strength of photographs without honestly assessing whether the journey is survivable.
How should you plan the days?
One thing a day, and not every day. Small children have limited capacity for organised activity, and a week of scheduled outings produces exhausted parents and fractious children.
Leave whole days with nothing planned. The activities children remember most are frequently the unstructured ones: a stream, a rock pool, a hill to roll down.
What should you check about the accommodation?
Whether the garden is enclosed and how securely, whether there is unfenced water nearby, whether the stairs are steep or open, and whether the cot and stair gate mentioned actually exist rather than being available on request.
Ask directly rather than assuming. Owners are used to these questions and a property that answers them vaguely is telling you something.
Does the weather decide it?
Less than you would expect, provided you planned for it. Every British family holiday includes wet days, and the ones that go well are the ones where an indoor option was identified before it started raining.
A property with space, a few games and a wet weather attraction within twenty minutes absorbs a bad forecast comfortably.
How long should it be?
A week for anywhere requiring a long journey, three or four nights for somewhere close. Short breaks with young children are dominated by packing, travelling and settling, and a two night trip is barely worth the effort involved.
By the third day children have adjusted and the holiday actually starts, which is an argument for staying longer rather than going more often.
What do parents consistently over think?
The itinerary, the attractions and the quality of the accommodation's interior. Children are largely indifferent to all three.
What they respond to is space to run, water in some form, other children, and adults who are relaxed. A holiday designed around those four things generally succeeds regardless of where it happens to be.
What is the honest test of a good family holiday?
Whether the adults get any rest. A week of driving between attractions is a logistics operation rather than a holiday, and parents return more tired than they left.
Choosing somewhere that entertains children with very little input, whether a beach, a farm, a forest or a park, is what makes the difference between a break and an expensive week of childcare in an unfamiliar kitchen.