The instinct on a short trip is either to book everything or to book nothing, and both produce problems. Over planning turns a weekend into a schedule; under planning wastes hours queueing or discovering that the thing you came for is fully reserved. The useful distinction is between what genuinely sells out and what does not.
What should you book first?
Travel, particularly by rail. Advance tickets are released several weeks ahead in limited quantities and the cheapest ones go first, with walk up fares on long routes costing several times as much.
Accommodation second, and immediately if your dates coincide with anything. A football match, a concert, a festival, a conference or a university graduation will fill a city's hotels and raise the remaining prices sharply.
Which attractions genuinely sell out?
Timed entry sites in the busiest cities: Edinburgh Castle, the Tower of London, Westminster Abbey and major temporary exhibitions. Anything with a limited daily capacity, including underground tours, cathedral tower climbs and small museums in historic buildings.
Booking these also usually costs less than the gate price, so there is no advantage to leaving it.
What does not need booking?
The free national museums, which have capacity and rarely queue outside school holidays. Cathedrals and parish churches. Markets, parks and anything outdoors.
General walking around, which is the majority of most city breaks and benefits from being unplanned.
Should you book restaurants?
The first night, yes. Arriving hungry into an unfamiliar city and then deciding is how people end up somewhere mediocre near the station.
Saturday night in a smaller city, also yes, since the good places are limited and fill by mid week. Weekday evenings and lunches can usually be left open, which gives you the flexibility to eat near wherever you happen to be.
How far ahead should you book each thing?
Rail as soon as tickets are released, typically eight to twelve weeks. Accommodation two to three months for ordinary weekends, six or more if an event coincides. Attractions two to four weeks. Restaurants one to two weeks for a Saturday.
Christmas market weekends and city centre hotels in December are the exception and behave like peak summer, going months ahead.
What should you check before booking anything?
What is happening in the city on your dates. A quick search of the city name with the weekend will surface fixtures, festivals and events, and it explains any accommodation price that looks strange compared with the weeks either side.
Also check for engineering works on the railway, which are published well in advance and frequently mean rail replacement buses at weekends.
Is free cancellation worth paying for?
Usually, for a modest premium. Prepaid non refundable rates save perhaps ten to twenty per cent and lose everything if plans change, which on a short domestic trip they often do.
The exception is a fixed event weekend where you will go regardless. In that case the cheaper prepaid rate is a reasonable bet.
What should you deliberately leave open?
The second evening, the Sunday morning and at least one afternoon. Cities reveal things you had not planned for, and a weekend booked solid removes any capacity to follow them.
The best moments on most city breaks are unscheduled, and a plan with no gaps in it guarantees you will not have any.
What if something you wanted is sold out?
Check for returns closer to the date, since cancellations release capacity and many attractions put unsold slots back on sale each morning. Some also hold back a small allocation for walk up visitors at opening time. Look for early or late entry slots, which sell last. Consider a guided tour, which sometimes has separate allocation from general admission. And keep a second option ready, because a weekend built around one unavailable attraction is a weekend with a hole in it, and most British cities have several alternatives within walking distance.